The Alternative Just Got Bigger

Forty days after the Justice Department named PayByPhone as the alternative to Arrive, PayByPhone bought HONK. The fight for digital parking payments is moving off-street.

By Andrew Sachs, PTMP November 17, 2026 7 MIN READ
Abstract network graphic: a large red cluster of connected dots linked by a dashed arc to a smaller dark cluster over parking stall lines, with a faint blue cluster in the corner

Forty days.

That is the gap between two documents that, read together, describe where digital parking payments in North America are headed. On October 8, the Justice Department’s Antitrust Division closed its review of Arrive’s purchase of Passport. Its reasoning rested in part on the finding that cities would still have meaningful alternatives if the combined company tried to exercise market power, and it named one of them: PayByPhone.1 On November 17, PayByPhone announced that it had completed its acquisition of HONK.2

The alternative just got bigger.

The deal at a glance

Buyer
PayByPhoneVancouver; owned by Lightyear Capital since March 31, 2026
Target
HONKToronto; founded 2013; payments, digital permits, reservations
Closed
Nov 17, 2026Terms not disclosed
PayByPhone footprint
~1,400 clientsCities and operators in six countries; 125 million plus app downloads
HONK footprint
Several hundredPrivate operators, universities and cities in the US and Canada
People
Michael BackHONK founder and CEO joins PayByPhone as Chief Growth Officer
Sources: PayByPhone and HONK announcement, Nov 17, 2026; Corpay Form 10-Q.

What PayByPhone bought

HONK sells mobile-first, unattended payments for parking: an app, text-to-park, scan-to-pay, digital permits and reservations. It describes its product as an asset-light parking management system for higher education, commercial real estate and municipal operators.23

PayByPhone brings scale and a new owner. Corpay sold the business to New York private equity firm Lightyear Capital in a deal that closed March 31, reporting roughly $420 million in net proceeds.48 HONK is Lightyear’s first add-on. The stated goals are to grow the North American client base, deepen the presence with universities and private operators, and speed up the North American product roadmap.2

Read that list again. Two of the three goals are about customers who are not cities.

2026: the year the field sorted itself

Arrive, the Swedish-headquartered parent of EasyPark, ParkMobile, RingGo, Flowbird and Parkopedia, closed on Passport this fall and gained citation issuance, permitting and more than 800 North American clients.56 PayByPhone, now independent and backed by private equity, has added HONK. And in February, Uber agreed to buy SpotHero, then last week put parking reservations inside the Uber app.7

2026: three buyers, one yearTimeline of 2026 deals. Arrive announced its acquisition of Passport on March 4 and the Justice Department closed its review on October 8. Corpay agreed in February to sell PayByPhone to Lightyear Capital, the sale closed March 31, and PayByPhone completed its acquisition of HONK on November 17. Uber agreed to buy SpotHero on February 25 and launched Uber Parking on November 9. The forty days between the Justice Department decision and the HONK acquisition are highlighted.Three buyers, one yearParking payment and reservation deals in North America, 202640 DAYSJANFEBMARAPRMAYJUNJULAUGSEPOCTNOVDECARRIVEPAYBYPHONEUBERPassport deal announced, Mar 4DOJ closes its review, Oct 8Sale to Lightyear signed, FebSale closes, Mar 31Buys HONK, Nov 17Agrees to buy SpotHero, Feb 25Uber Parking launches, Nov 9Sources: DOJ Antitrust Division; Corpay Form 10-Q; Arrive; PayByPhone; Uber. Feb date for the Lightyear agreement is approximate.
Figure 1. Three buyers, one year. The highlighted band marks the forty days between the Justice Department closing its Arrive and Passport review and PayByPhone completing its HONK acquisition. Sources: DOJ Antitrust Division; Corpay Form 10-Q; company announcements.

It would be easy to call this a duopoly. The Justice Department looked hard at exactly that question and concluded otherwise, noting that smaller vendors have recently won municipal contracts.1 On-street payments for cities remain a competitive, RFP-driven market, and cities still hold the pen. What the year did change is the shape of the big players. Each buyer filled a different gap.

Figure 2

Three buyers, three different gaps filled

Arrive

bought Passport

What it added

  • Citations
  • Permitting
  • Curbside payments

800+

Passport clients across North America

PayByPhone

bought HONK

What it added

  • Off-street payments
  • Digital permits
  • Reservations

Hundreds

HONK operator, university and city clients

Uber

bought SpotHero

What it added

  • Reservation marketplace
  • Garage inventory

13,000+

Garages, lots and valets in about 400 cities

Figure 2. Capabilities as described in each company’s own announcement. Sources: Arrive and Passport; PayByPhone and HONK; Uber and SpotHero.

The new front is off-street

On-street mobile payment is a maturing product in most large cities. The open territory is off-street: campus lots, private surface lots, mixed-use garages, hospital and office parking. Much of that inventory has stayed uncontrolled because a gate, a booth and an attendant never penciled. Gateless systems built on license plate recognition and a phone in the driver’s hand change that math, and HONK built its business there.

Same phone, different customerTwo panels. On the left, on-street parking at a curb, where the city is the customer and contracts are won through public procurement. On the right, a gateless off-street lot where a camera reads the plate of an arriving car and the driver pays by phone; the customer is a university, private operator or property owner.Same phone, different customerWhere the growth in digital parking payments is movingON-STREETPPAYCustomer: the cityWon by: public RFPOFF-STREET, GATELESSPLATE READCustomer: university, operator, ownerWon by: the facility’s PARCS designIllustrative. Gateless control pairs plate recognition with mobile payment, replacing gate, booth and attendant.
Figure 3. Same phone, different customer. On the street, the city buys. Off-street, the facility owner buys, and the payment platform becomes part of access and revenue control. Illustrative.

PayByPhone did not buy an app. It bought a route into facilities where the city is not the customer.

Andrew Sachs

That has a direct consequence for owners and operators. When the payment platform is also the access and revenue control layer, the choice of payment vendor becomes a PARCS architecture decision. It should be made the same way: start from the operating requirements and the software capabilities you need, and let the vendor fit the design rather than the other way around.

Why universities matter here

Higher education is the quiet center of this deal. A campus is a small city with a single landlord: permits, visitor parking, event days, enforcement and a population that turns over every fall. HONK built its permit and campus business there, and PayByPhone named universities explicitly.2 A digital permit tied to a plate is more than a convenience. It becomes the parker’s account, the enforcement record and the occupancy data at once, which is why whoever holds the permit relationship holds the campus.

Five moves for owners, operators and cities

  • Read your change-of-control clause this week. If you contract with HONK, your vendor now has a new parent. Know your rights on assignment, pricing, service levels and termination before the integration plan reaches you.
  • Own the convenience-fee decision. Driver-paid session fees are the quiet economics of mobile payment. Decide who pays, how much, and whether the fee differs by channel, and put that policy in the contract rather than in the vendor’s app settings.
  • Make data portability a requirement, not a request. Session, plate and permit data feed enforcement, PARCS reporting and rate setting. Require open APIs, regular data exports and a clean exit path so a platform change never strands your history.
  • Do not procure as if there are only two vendors. The Justice Department’s own finding is that smaller vendors are winning contracts. A competitive RFP with a real third option is the best protection against consolidation pricing.
  • Treat permits as the account. For campuses and permit-heavy operators, the permit system now defines the customer relationship. Choose it with the same care as the payment app, because increasingly they are the same product.

What we still do not know

The announcement does not say whether the HONK brand and app will survive, how existing HONK users will be migrated, or how HONK’s integrations with operator partners will be handled. Both companies say clients and drivers will see business as usual, with no service disruption.2 The release does not address enforcement, the capability Arrive gained with Passport, or whether pricing and fees will change. We will update this note as those answers arrive. For the reservation side of the same shift, see our analysis of Uber and SpotHero.

Andrew Sachs, PTMP, is president of Gateway Parking Services, a parking consultancy and systems integrator.

Sources

  1. US Department of Justice, “Statement of the Department of Justice Antitrust Division on the Closing of Its Investigation of Arrive AS’s Proposed Acquisition of Passport Labs Inc.,” Oct. 8, 2026. justice.gov
  2. PayByPhone and HONK, “PayByPhone Acquires HONK, Expanding its Parking Payments Platform Across North America,” Nov. 17, 2026. honkmobile.com
  3. Parking Today, “PayByPhone Acquires HONK,” Nov. 17, 2026. parkingtoday.com
  4. Corpay, Inc., Form 10-Q for the quarter ended June 30, 2026 (sale of PayByPhone). sec.gov
  5. Passport, “Arrive announces intent to acquire Passport,” Mar. 4, 2026. passportinc.com
  6. Pulse 2.0, “Arrive Completes Acquisition Of Passport To Build City OS For Autonomous Mobility.” pulse2.com
  7. Uber Newsroom, “Uber Parking has arrived,” Nov. 9, 2026; Pulse 2.0, “Uber Acquires SpotHero To Add Parking Reservations,” Feb. 25, 2026. uber.com
  8. Lightyear Capital, “Lightyear Capital Signs Agreement to Acquire PayByPhone.” lycap.com
Share LinkedIn Facebook X
Andrew Sachs, PTMPA
About the Author
Andrew Sachs, PTMP

Andrew Sachs, PTMP, is co-founder and editor of Parkonomics and President of Gateway Parking Services, a parking consultancy and PARCS systems integrator.

Read Next